Corporate clinics cop scrutiny over MBS maximisation

4 minute read


Bupa-owned GP practices have been the subject of multiple mainstream media reports over the last few days.


Senator David Pocock has called out GP clinics which scrutinise the books of their GPs and encourage them to rebook eligible patients for high-value services, saying “if that’s not illegal, it should be”.  

Health insurer Bupa has been at the centre of a media storm this week, after the ABC reported on an email allegedly sent by a practice manager at a Bupa-owned clinic urging GPs to book more patients for chronic condition management plans.  

According to the ABC, the email encouraged GPs to book eligible patients for further checks on a separate day, in order to get around Medicare rules preventing GPs from billing the same patient for multiple services in one day.  

The article said the email mentioned a Bupa “ops team” which had apparently “tasked the practice managers with ‘ensuring revenue is increasing by ensuring there is an uptick in billings of HA [health assessments]’,” and that the practice managers had been closely scrutinising practitioners’ books using Cubiko’s QuickCheck function.  

The ABC did not specify which of the 33 medical centres currently operated by Bupa the letter came from.  

Bupa is still in the process of acquiring an additional 68 clinics from the Partnered Health network. When that deal is complete, the insurer will be the fifth-largest general practice group in the country. 

Mr Pocock, an independent senator for the ACT, raised the ABC article in parliament yesterday, noting that Bupa also held government contracts with Home Affairs, the Australian Defence Force, and the Department of Veterans’ Affairs.  

“Today the ABC reported that it had obtained an email from one Bupa medical clinic encouraging doctors to increase revenue by billing more chronic condition management plans,” Mr Pocock said.  

“The email indicated that appointment books were being scrutinised for potential possible service opportunities. It encouraged doctors to rebook eligible patients for additional services when Medicare rules prevented services being claimed on the same day.  

“Not only is that a disgusting loss of productivity; if that’s not illegal, it should be.  

“When the ABC asked Bupa why, it said all it was doing was encouraging preventive care. It seems to me that this is a multinational that is taking us for a ride.” 

Bupa told The Medical Republic that the practice managers’ email was intended “to remind doctors to consider preventive care and chronic condition management services for eligible patients, and to bill the relevant Medicare items where permitted and clinically appropriate”.  

Final decisions about patient care and billing, it said, would always remain with the treating clinician.  

When asked more specifically about the purported reference to a Bupa “ops team” in the practice manager’s email, Bupa said the wording did “not accurately describe our Operations team’s role”. 

“The team helps GP clinics run smoothly so doctors can focus on caring for patients. This includes reminding doctors to consider preventive care, health checks or follow-up care,” a spokesperson for Bupa said.   

“The team does not make clinical decisions, recommend Medicare items or tell doctors how to bill. Those decisions are for the treating doctor alone. 

“The treating doctor decides whether a service is clinically appropriate and necessary, and whether relevant Medicare requirements have been met.  

“We believe preserving clinical autonomy of our doctors and healthcare providers and allowing them to make independent decisions is fundamentally important to delivering the best health outcomes for a patient. 

“Our practice managers provide administrative support to our doctors.” 

Software provider Cubiko, whose product, QuickCheck, was named in the article, said it “respects the clinical autonomy of general practitioners”.  

QuickCheck works by identifying areas where practitioners can optimise billing by checking whether patients are eligible for certain items, such as chronic condition management plans or mental health treatment plans.  

Its interface presents a dollar figure showing the potential value of the missed billings. 

“Chronic disease is significantly under-managed in Australian general practice, and Cubiko’s tools help practices identify patients who may have unmet care needs,” a Cubiko spokesperson told TMR.  

“Where a GP determines care is clinically relevant, Cubiko supports practices to ensure any Medicare items claimed meet the strict eligibility criteria set by Medicare therefore reducing, not increasing, the risk of incorrect billing.”  

End of content

No more pages to load

Log In Register ×